DIY or outsource SEO services for your private practice? How to make the right choice

Why therapists need SEO more than other professionals

Unlike other business owners who may rely on a global audience, therapists depend on local clients—meaning SEO is critical for making sure the right people in your area find your practice. When someone searches for “therapist near me” or “anxiety therapy in [your city],” you want your website to show up first.


But ranking at the top of search engines doesn’t happen by accident. Without a solid SEO strategy, potential clients may never even see your website, let alone book a session with you.


As a web designer and SEO specialist for therapists, I’ve seen firsthand how a well-optimized website can transform a private practice. In this blog, we’ll cover:


  • The ROI of SEO: Is it worth it for therapists?
  • Common mistakes and frustrations therapists face with DIY SEO
  • How to determine if SEO should be on your to-do list
  • Where to find SEO services for therapists
  • What to consider before hiring SEO services
  • Why outsourcing SEO can be the best investment for your practice


The ROI of SEO: Is it worth it for therapists?

SEO isn’t an expense—it’s an investment. According to digital marketing expert Neil Patel, businesses that invest in SEO see long-term, compounding returns because organic search brings in consistent, high-quality leads without ongoing ad spend.


Consider this:

  • Unlike paid ads, which stop bringing traffic once your budget runs out, SEO continues driving clients month after month—without additional spending.
  • Websites on the first page of Google get 92% of traffic, while those on page two or beyond get less than 6%—meaning visibility is everything.


SEO isn’t just about ranking—it’s about making sure the right people find you at the right time.


The frustrations of DIY SEO: What therapists get wrong


Many therapists try to handle SEO themselves to save money, but DIY SEO often leads to:


1. Wasting hours on strategies that don’t work

Google’s algorithm is constantly evolving, and outdated SEO tactics (like keyword stuffing or spammy backlinks) can hurt your rankings instead of helping.


2. Picking the wrong keywords can hurt your rankings

Many therapists make the mistake of choosing keywords that don’t align with how potential clients search for services. You might assume that ranking for broad terms like 'mental health support' is effective, but local clients are more likely to search for 'anxiety therapist in [your city]' or 'trauma counseling near me.' If you’re not optimizing for the right search terms, your website won’t reach the right audience.


  • Ignoring local SEO (Therapists need location-based keywords to attract nearby clients.)
  • Overusing broad terms (Highly competitive and less likely to bring in local clients.)
  • Not researching client search behavior (SEO should be based on how real people search for therapy services.)


Choosing the wrong keywords can result in low website traffic and missed opportunities to connect with clients who need your help. An SEO professional ensures that your site is optimized for high-intent keywords that bring in actual therapy clients, not just website visitors.


3. Burnout from learning a completely new skill

Your time is valuable. Do you really want to spend nights and weekends watching SEO tutorials when you could be focusing on your clients?


Is SEO something that should be on your to-do list?

If you’re asking yourself, “Can I afford to delegate SEO?”, flip the question:

  • Can you afford NOT to rank on Google?
  • How many potential clients are you missing out on because they can’t find you online?
  • How much is your time worth—and is DIY SEO really the best use of it?


Outsourcing SEO means:

  • You get results faster with expert-backed strategies.
  • You free up your time to focus on therapy instead of marketing.
  • You eliminate the frustration of trying to figure out SEO on your own.


Where to find SEO services for therapists


If you decide to outsource, there are several options:


1. Specialized SEO services for therapists

Working with an SEO professional who understands therapy-specific keywords, ethical marketing, and client conversion strategies makes a huge difference.


2. Marketing agencies

Some larger marketing agencies offer SEO for therapists, but they often use a generic approach rather than one tailored to your practice.


3. Freelance SEO experts

Hiring an SEO freelancer can be a cost-effective option, but make sure they understand the therapy industry and local SEO strategies.


What to consider before hiring SEO services

Not all SEO providers are equal. Before hiring anyone, ask:


  • Do they specialize in SEO for therapists?
  • Will they focus on local SEO to bring in clients from your area?
  • Do they offer ongoing optimization, or just a one-time setup?
  • Will they provide transparency on what strategies they’re using?
  • Do they also optimize website content for better conversion rates?


If an SEO company can’t explain their strategies clearly, that’s a red flag.


SEO doesn’t have to be a full-time job for you

You don’t have to DIY every aspect of your marketing—especially if it’s draining your time and energy. My monthly SEO + website management starts at $97/month, giving you:

  • A fully optimized website that ranks higher on Google
  • Ongoing SEO management so your rankings improve over time
  • Monthly reports so you can track your growth
  • A hands-off approach so you don’t have to stress about it


Let’s be real—you became a therapist to help people, not spend your weekends learning SEO. If you’re ready to take SEO off your plate and let an expert handle it, let’s chat.


🔗 Book a consultation here.



Related reads therapist marketing:


hiring seo services for therapists

* AI Disclosure: This content may contain sections generated with AI with the purpose of providing you with condensed helpful and relevant content, however all personal opinions are 100% human made as well as the blog post structure, outline and key takeaways.

* Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links on www.nataliamaganda.com may contain affiliate links meaning that I will get a commission for recommending products at no extra cost to you.


hello! i'm natalia

Latina, web design expert for mental health professionals.

I help ambitious life coaches, therapists and holistic leaders amplify their magic, gain visibility, and simplify their marketing efforts through strategic web design and content. 

podcast for therapists
By Natalia Gomez January 31, 2025
Why would a non-therapist start a podcast for therapists? Learn how my mission to reduce therapist burnout, support marketing clarity, and promote an abundant mindset is fueling this podcast.
therapist burnout
By Natalia Gomez January 31, 2025
Feeling overwhelmed as a therapist? Learn how my clients recover from therapist burnout by outsourcing their website, SEO, and marketing automation—so they can focus on what they love.
therapist website template
By Natalia Gomez January 31, 2025
Thinking about using a therapist website template? Learn what to consider before buying one, what to include for conversion, and whether you should DIY or hire a designer.
entrepreneur in healthcare
By Natalia Gomez January 31, 2025
Thinking about starting your own healthcare business? This guide breaks down what it takes to become a healthcare entrepreneur, the most profitable opportunities, and how to succeed with less stress
therapy termination letter
By Natalia Gomez January 31, 2025
Need to write a therapy termination letter? This guide explains when and how therapists can ethically end treatment, plus provides three customizable examples and prompts.
private pay vs insurance
By Natalia Gomez January 30, 2025
Should you accept insurance or focus on private pay in your therapy practice? This guide breaks down the pros and cons of both options so you can make the best decision for your business.